Comparability preview
Get your free board report →
Ayres Memorial Animal Shelter Inc
EIN 237349952 · NY · NTEE D200 · revenue $337,638 · FY 2023-12-31
$
Pick the role and type the pay your board is considering — everything below updates as you type. We only compare against the same role.
0th percentile
We compared this Executive Director / CEO's pay to 22 similar animal-related nonprofits of about the same size, adjusted for NY cost of living and inflation.
MELANIE SHIBLEY · reported title "TREASURER" — selected as the highest-paid individual; verify the role.
How we chose them
Every comparable organization in the band — 22 in total — matched by Same NTEE sector (D20) + NY + budget 0.67–1.5× revenue, and selected by rule, not hand-picked. Peer pay is normalized to NY cost of living (BEA Regional Price Parities) and to the subject's filing year (CPI-U). Full methodology →
| Organization | State | Revenue | Total comp | Filing |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Ruff House Rescue Inc | NY | $337,422 | $113,935 | 990 → |
| Oswego County Humane Society Inc | NY | $342,786 | $49,406 | 990 → |
| Wonder Dog Rescue | NY | $350,452 | $87,418 | 990 → |
| Aruba Flight Volunteers Inc | NY | $319,071 | $49,980 | 990 → |
| A New Chance Animal Rescue Inc | NY | $318,086 | $63,135 | 990 → |
| 🔒 +17 more comparable organizations — the full peer set, sources, and CSV export are included in your board report. | ||||
Generate the board-ready determination
A formatted PDF with the full 22-organization peer set, the distribution, the methodology, and ready-to-adopt 26 CFR 53.4958-6 board-minutes language — timestamped to attach to your minutes. A screenshot of a webpage isn't board minutes. It's free for your organization's size.