PeerBasis
Education · NY

Cardinal Hayes School

Cardinal Hayes School reported paying Mary Sontheimer, Executive Director, $29,460 in total compensation (FY 2025).

That places Mary Sontheimer at approximately the 0th percentile among 17 similarly sized education nonprofits (median $169,389).

$4,684,824Total revenue (FY 2025)
$29,460Total executive compensation
0thPercentile vs. peers

Setting executive pay for this board?

Generate a board-ready comparability report for Cardinal Hayes School — named comparables, percentiles, methodology, and the 26 CFR 53.4958-6 minutes language a board can use toward the rebuttable presumption.

Build the comparability report →

Comparable education nonprofits

Compensation is normalized to NY cost of living (BEA Regional Price Parities); each organization's reported figure is on its linked 990.

OrganizationStateRevenueTotal comp
The Center For Handicapped Children Inc NY$4,566,565 $117,121
Heartshare Education Center NY$4,550,853 $54,753
The Lorge School NY$4,458,586 $200,233
George Jackson Academy NY$4,953,988 $256,615
Milestones Children's Center NY$5,064,230 $187,220
Small Wonder Preschool Inc NY$5,095,405 $264,330
The Elija School NY$4,157,690 $169,389
Reach For The Stars Learning Center NY$5,294,383 $227,473

View original IRS filings on ProPublica →